Copyright laws
must've been lame in 1861 when John Bartlett pretty much plagiarized
the work of Judge Staples' Documentary History of the Destruction of
the Gaspee, written only 16 years earlier. But Bartlett's
text is exceedingly hard to find in the year 2004, so we present it
here to aid in scholarly citations. To be honest, Staples,
particularly the 1990 republication by the RI Historical Publications
Society, is a more honest read. John Russell Bartlett (1805-1880)
was a historian most noted for publishing the multi-volume Records of the Colony of Rhode Island and
Providence Plantations between 1856 and 1865. He married
the daughter of the prominent General Christopher Rhodes, and lived in
Pawtuxet Village. It is no wonder then that he had a particular
fondness for the retelling of the Gaspee Affair.
The following text
of The Destruction
of the Gaspee is reprinted from the edition published in Providence
by A. Crawford Greene in 1861. Rather than rescan and OCR the
entire
text, we used as a starting point, the 1991 republication of
Staples, Documentary History of the
Destruction of the Gaspee,
presented also at this web site. Paragraph structure and page
numbers were altered to match that found in Bartlett's presentation.
His relatively few original comments were either typed in directly, or
scanned in to the text at the appropriate places, all of which are
presented in <Arial
bold font>, and his footnotes are presented in
<Bold Times font>. Orphaned
text has
been completed into the page of origin. Otherwise, the
texts
follow their original printed sources as closely as the present format
allows.
Antique words and
phraseology
were maintained as best as possible, but will come up as errors in
grammar
checks and spell checks or modern word processing programs, so be
advised.
It is also to be noted that the spellings of some words used in
Staples'
account are consistently misspelled by year 2004 standards, but which
were
presumably correctly spelt in 1773, e.g., 'despatched' and 'enquiry.'
Please
understand that neither myself or the Gaspee Days Committee can take
any
responsibility for errors of omission or commission in converting the
text
into HTML format.
And further, this
despondant saeth not.
Dr. John Concannon
Webmaster, Gaspee Virtual Archives, August, 2004.
webmaster@gaspee.org
A History
of the Destruction
of
His Britannic Majesty's
Schooner Gaspee,
In Narragansett Bay,
On the 10th of June 1772:
Accompanied by the
Correspondence Connected Therewith; The Action of
the General Assembly of Rhode Island Thereon,
and the
Official Journal of the Proceedings
of the
Commission of Inquiry Appointed by King George
the Third, on the Same.
by
John Russell Bartlett,
Secretary of State
Providence:
A. Crawford Greene, Printer to the State.
1861.
A History
of the Destruction
of
His Britannic Majesty's
Schooner Gaspee,
In Narragansett Bay,
On the 10th of June 1772:
Accompanied by the
Correspondence Connected Therewith; The Action of
the General Assembly of Rhode Island Thereon,
and the
Official Journal of the Proceedings
of the
Commission of Inquiry Appointed by King George
the Third, on the Same.
by
John Russell Bartlett,
Secretary of State
Providence:
A. Crawford Greene, Printer to the State.
1861.
It is suspected he has no legal
authority to justify his conduct,
and
his commission, if he has any, is some antiquated paper, more of a
fiction
than any thing else, and this seems to be confirmed by Mr. Thomas
Greene,
who says he saw it, and believes it to be no other than the commission
the famous Reid had, who lost his sloop at Newport, or something else
of
no validity.
In consequence of the above mentioned application, I have consulted with the Chief Justice Hopkins thereon, who is of opinion, that no commander of any vessel has any right to use any authority in the body of the colony without previously applying to the Governor and showing his warrant for so doing and also being sworn to a due exercise of his office—and this he informs me has been the common custom in this Colony.
I am, sir, &c, &c,
The letter led to
the following correspondence between the
Governor
and the commanding officer of the schooner:
I am your humble servant,
Lieut. Dudingston to the Governor
of Rhode Island
In answer to which, I have done nothing but what was my duty, and their complaint can only be founded on their ignorance of that. When I waited on you, on my arrival, I acquainted you of my being sent to this government to assist the revenue. I had my commission to show you if required, as it was ever understood by all his Majesty's governors I have had the honor to wait on, that every officer commanding one of his Majesty's vessels was properly authorized and never did produce it, unasked for. The officer I send is equally qualified, and has been in the boats in boarding most of the vessels, and can give any information relative to my proceeding.
Sir, your humble servant,
I am your humble servant,
With this, the correspondence between the Governor Wanton and Lieut. Dudingston ended. The Lieutenant's sense of propriety was evidently shocked by the letters from Governor Wanton, and of his peremptory demand to exhibit to him his commission and instructions. He seems to have believed that the authority from which his commission emanated, was paramount to that of the colonial governor. He therefore enclosed the letters of Governor Wanton, together with his own, to Admiral Montagu, at Boston, who was then in command of His Majesty's fleet on this station. The Admiral plainly espoused the side of Dudingston, and feeling his own dignity wounded at the demand of the Governor on his lieutenant, addressed the insolent letter, which follows, to Gov. Wanton:
I shall give them directions, that, in case they receive any molestation in the execution of their duty, they shall send every man so taken in molesting them, to me. I am also informed, the people of Newport talk of fitting out an armed vessel to rescue any vessel the King's schooner may take carrying on an illicit trade. Let them be cautious what they do; for as sure as they attempt it, and any of them are taken, I will hang them as pirates. I shall report your two insolent letters to my officer, to his Majesty's secretaries of state, and leave them to determine what right you have to demand a sight of all orders I shall give to all officers of my squadron, and I would advise you not to send your sheriff on board the King's ship again, on such ridiculous errands. The captain and lieutenants have all my orders to give you assistance whenever you demand it, but further you have no business with them, and, be assured, it is not their duty to show you any part of my orders or instructions to them.
I am, sir, &c, &c
This produced the following dignified and spirited answer:
The Governor laid the proceeding letter from Admiral Montagu before the General Assembly, at their May session 1772, and the following resolution passed that body in relation to the answer sent to the Admiral.To Admiral Montagu
"Resolved, That His Honor the Governor be requested to transmit a copy of the written letter to Admiral Montagu, and likewise , that his Honor, the Governor, be requested to transmit to the secretary of state, a narration, containing the proceedings referred to in said letter, together with a copy of the Admiral's letter, as soon as may be, and that he present a copy thereof to this Assembly at the next session of the same."
The letter of the Governor led to some further correspondence between the admiral and the lieutenant, of which only the following letter is found among the archives:
Lieut.
Dudingston to Admiral Montagu.
SIR:—I have received your letters
of the 14th and 18th inst and copy
of commissioners to you. By theirs, I see plainly, I cannot look to
them
to be supported for sending the sloop and rum to Boston,
notwithstanding
I was assured by their officers at this port, no seizure could be safe
with them. There was only the alternative to send her or remain in this
harbor and guard twelve hogsheads of rum, a bait, the inhabitants of
this
government would willingly put in my way, if that could fix the
schooner.
I was not, at the time, ignorant
of the statute to the contrary, but
never
doubted if the sloop got safe I should be supported by them, as I
informed
the board.
The owner of the rum resided in
Coventry, which is but
little
further from Boston than Newport, of course could, at as little
expense,
defend his property at the one as the other. As I find the exigencies
not
considered, but law referred to by them, for the future shall take care
not to act repugnant to it, let what may be the consequence. If I
should
have any doubt about that, will take the opinion recommended to their
officers
relative to the officers in the Navy being arrested here by the
Attorney
General. I shall also be on my guard not to put it in their power to
arrest
me or any officer under my command in this government.
What passed
between
the governor and me was, near as I can recollect, what follows. The
morning
after my arrival from Boston was when I first saw him.
Lieut D.—Sir, I command his majesty's schooner Gaspee, and am ordered into this government by Admiral Montagu, to assist the revenue.
Governor—Is it the schooner Capt. Allen commanded? (meaning the Lieutenant I superseded.)
Lieut..—Yes.
Governor—We have had many different schooners here lately, (mentioning the Sultana, St. John and Halifax.)
Lieut.—Yes; and you may remember me here about two years ago when the Colonels Dalrymple and Robinson came with me. (I am not sure whether he said he did or not.)
Governor—What vessel was that which seized the Packet?
I told him whom she was commanded by and belonged to, and my being there at the time, and said, it would not have happened had the officer come near the Gaspee, which was his duty, with more on the subject too trivial for you to hear. He then related the conduct of the collector and Mr. Reid, late commander of the custom house sloop Liberty, and said it was in their power to have saved her before she had received much damage, and said he would not mind what they represented concerning him, if they had told facts. I said I had heard it otherwise mentioned, but hoped I should meet with no difficulty in the execution of my duty.
Governor—You may depend on my
support and assistance.
I then observed, it was not clear to me, if I made a seizure it would be safe.
Governor—I will do all in my power.
I then instanced what had been the fate of one made by the officers of the port a little before, and added, I did not think if I made one I should put it to the trial.
Governor—I suppose you will be much here. I shall always be glad to see you.
Lieut. D.—I shall be where I find
I can best execute the service.
I was much obliged to him.
Governor—I hope, Captain, we shall have a good understanding.
I must now beg leave to observe,
if he had asked me to
show my orders, is it possible I should behave so much unlike an
officer
and gentleman in telling a falsehood, by doing which I must be ruined
as
an officer and in reputation forever?
The fallacy is easily seen when it is considered, the only thing
that
makes the schooner respected, is said to be denied by me. Had such an
assertion
come from a private character, I should hope for reparation for an
attempt
to wound my reputation as an officer. In my present situation I have
only
to hope my person will be respected as an officer as much as any
Governor,
who can make it appear by no better evidence than an old woman and
clerk
in the naval office, and not in the station of a gentleman, and I do
not
think either would be base enough to witness so great a falsehood.
As
to
his letter, it cannot be looked upon as his, but the Assembly's, where
it was put to the vote to answer your letter or not. They were all for
the answer, the Governor alone, for sending it to Lord Hillsborough.
Mr. Greene is one of the house, the owner of the rum. I could expect no quarter from people of that stamp. On the 20th the sloop was condemned. I have taken the liberty to enclose my letter to the Commissioners for your perusal, open, as it was the intention of the people here to have the sloop sold in the manner they have been used to, which always falls into the old owners' hands without opposition. I hope soon to have the board's answer to determine her destination.
I am, sir, &c, &c,
At the next session
of
the Assembly, which was in August following, and to which reference is
made in Colonial Records, Vol. VII, p. 51, Governor Wanton presented a
copy
of his letter to the secretary of state, which was as follows:
As Admiral Montagu has endeavored to fix a stigma on my character and administration as Governor of this Colony, by charging me with attempting to distress the King's officers from strictly complying with his orders, Your Lordship will indulge me with giving a short account of my proceedings, by which the ungenerous accusation of Admiral Montagu will, I flatter myself, appear not to have the least foundation in truth.
On the 21st of March last, a number of the inhabitants of this colony, gentlemen of established character, and whose loyalty to their sovereign is not to be questioned, exhibited to me a complaint in writing, that a certain schooner was cruising in the Narragansett river, boarding every vessel and boat that passed, and otherwise interrupting them in the pursuit of their lawful business; and not knowing by what authority the persons belonging to said schooner exercised that power within the body of the colony, requested me to make such enquiry concerning the same as was consistent with law.
It, therefore, became my
indispensable duty, in order to satisfy the
complaints, to demand of the commanding officer of said schooner, the
reason
of his thus acting, and whether he was vested with such power as would
justify his proceedings, which produced my letter to him of the 22d of
March. It was answered by Wm. Dudingston, of the schooner Gaspee, but,
as he did not give me that satisfaction I conceived I had an
indisputable
right to expect, I wrote another letter, whereupon he sent me by one of
his officers, an order from the Lords of the Admiralty, for his
commanding
the schooner Gaspee; also their letter to the commissioners at Boston
requesting
that board to give him a deputation in the customs, both which I
returned
to the officer in the same hour he brought them, without attempting in
the least to distress or oppose him in the execution of his duty.
This, my Lord, is a true state of facts, and, I believe, your Lordship is convinced that, in my proceedings, I have done nothing but what was my duty, and that Admiral Montagu's accusation is as groundless as it is illiberal.
When I wrote my first letter, I do
upon honour declare, that I did
not
know whether the schooner complained of was the Gaspee or not, and even
if I did, in my opinion I am justifiable, as I was entirely
unacquainted
with Mr. Dudingston's authority, either as an officer in the revenue or
navy; and, I do not believe, he had any right to officiate as a custom
house officer within the body of this colony, before he had
communicated
to me, or some proper authority, his commission for so doing.
I must
not
omit mentioning, that the information which Admiral Montagu says he has
received that the people of Newport talk of fitting out an armed vessel
to rescue any seizures which may be made by the King's vessels, is,
Your
Lordship may be assured, a malicious representation, calculated, by the
enemies of our happy constitution, to injure the colony, and bring upon
the inhabitants his Majesty's displeasure.
I acknowledge it a singular happiness, that this affair is brought before Your Lordship, and that your candor and inflexible integrity will fix the charge of insolence where it really belongs. I submit the dispute, with pleasure, from a thorough conviction that Your Lordship's opinion thereupon will be consonant to the strictest equity.
It is now my turn to complain of
Wm. Dudingston's illegal
proceedings,
in carrying a quantity of rum he had seized on board a small boat,
lying
within the county of Kent, in this colony, to Boston, for trial,
notwithstanding
by the 8th of his present Majesty, it is expressly declared, that all
forfeitures
of this kind shall be tried in that colony where the offence is
committed.
To recite every particular of his unwarrantable proceedings, would, My Lord, be tedious. Let it then suffice, that since the Gaspee and Beaver have been stationed in this colony, the inhabitants have been insulted without any just cause, with the most abusive and contumelious language, and I am sorry that I have reason to say, that the principal officers belonging to said vessels have exercised that power with which they are vested, in a wanton and arbitrary manner, to the very great injury and disturbance of the colony.
I have, my Lord, constantly afforded the King's officers all the assistance in my power in the legal discharge of their trust; if any of them through prejudice, ignorance of their duty or youthful indiscretion, insult the colony, it is my duty, as his Majesty's governor, to remonstrate against it.
I am, &c, &c
The foregoing
letters present an account of the events which preceded the memorable
night of the 9th of June, when the Gaspee was destroyed. That
Dudingston did not act wisely, to say the least, in exerting the
authority he did, without first exhibiting his commission, is evident.
But it is certain, that in sending some of the property seized by him,
within the jurisdiction of the county of Kent, in Rhode Island, to
Boston, there to be adjudicated upon by the court of vice admiralty, he
was clearly in the wrong; as an act of Parliament expressly declares
that such seizures shall bo adjudicated in the colony where the seizure
is made. The goods here referred to, consisted of twelve
hogsheads of
rum, and some sugars, which were on board a sloop, bound from Greenwich
to Newport, and were the property of Jacob Greene & Co., of Warwick.*
Dudingston seems to have been aware that this act was an illegal one,
as he did not dare to go on shore, having been threatened with a suit
at law by the owners of the goods.
Next in order, is the. destruction of the Gaspee, the narrative of the
particulars of which, we shall give, as written by Col. Ephraim Bowen,
the last survivor of the party which de-
stroyed this vessel.
"In
the year 1772, the British government had stationed at Newport,
Rhode Island, the schooner called the Gaspee, of eight guns,
commanded
by Wm. Dudingston, a Lieutenant in the British Navy, for the purpose of
preventing the clandestine landing of articles, subject to the payment
of duty.
______________________
The captain of this schooner made it his practice to stop and
board all vessels entering or leaving the ports of Rhode Island, or
leaving
Newport for Providence.
Lindsey was standing easterly, with the tide on ebb
about
two hours, when he hove about, at the end of Namquit Point, and stood
to
the westward, and Dudingston in close chase, changed his course and ran
on the Point, near its end, and grounded.
Lindsey continued on his
course
up the river, and arrived at Providence about sunset, when he
immediately
informed Mr. John Brown, one of our first and most respectable
merchants,
of the situation of the Gaspee. He immediately concluded that she would
remain immovable until after midnight, and that now an opportunity
offered
of putting an end to the trouble and vexation she daily caused.
Mr.
Brown
immediately resolved on her destruction, and he forthwith directed one
of his trusty shipmasters to collect eight of the largest long-boats in
the harbor, with five oars to each, to have the oars and row-locks well
muffled, to prevent noise, and to place them at Fenner's wharf,
directly
opposite to the dwelling of Mr. James Sabin, who kept a house of board
and entertainment for gentlemen, being the same house purchased a few
years
after by the late Welcome Arnold, and is now owned by and is the
residence
of Colonel Richard J. Arnold, his son*
___________________________
About the time of the shutting up of the shops soon after sunset, a man passed along the main street beating a drum and informing the inhabitants of the fact, that the Gaspee was aground on Namquit Point, and would not float off until 3 o'clock the next morning, and inviting those persons who felt a disposition to go and destroy that troublesome vessel, to repair in the evening to Mr. James Sabin's house. About 9 o'clock, I took my father's gun and my powder horn and bullets and went to Mr. Sabin's, and found the southeast room full of people, where I loaded my gun, and all remained there till about 10 o'clock, some casting bullets in the kitchen, and others making arrangements for departure, when orders were given to cross the street to Fenner's wharf and embark; which soon took place, and a sea captain acted as steersman of each boat, of whom I recollect Capt. Abraham Whipple, Capt. John B. Hopkins, (with whom I embarked,) and Capt. Benjamin Dunn. A line from right to left was soon formed, with Capt. Whipple on the right and Capt. Hopkins on the right of the left wing.
The party thus proceeded till within about sixty yards of the
Gaspee,
when a sentinel hailed, "Who comes there"? No answer. He hailed again
and
no answer.
In about a minute Duddingston mounted the starboard gunwale
in his shirt and hailed, "Who comes there?" No answer.
He hailed again, when Capt. Whipple answered as follows:
"I am the
sheriff
of the county of Kent, G—d d—n you. I have got a warrant to apprehend
you,
G—d d—n you; so surrender, G—d d—n you.''
__________________________
I took my seat on the main
thwart,
near the larboard row-lock, with my gun by my right side, facing
forwards.
As soon as Dudingston began to hail, Joseph Bucklin, who was
standing
on
the main thwart by my right side, said to me, "Ephe, reach me your gun
and I can kill that fellow.'' I reached it to him accordingly, when,
during
Capt. Whipple's replying, Bucklin fired and Dudingston fell, and
Bucklin
exclaimed, " I have killed the rascal."
In less than a minute after Capt. Whipple's answer, the boats were alongside of the Gaspee, and boarded without opposition. The men on deck retreated below as Dudingston entered the cabin.
As it was discovered that he was wounded, John Mawney, who had for
two
or three years been studying physic and surgery, was ordered to go into
the cabin and dress Dudingston's wound, and I was directed to assist
him.
On examination, it was found the ball took effect about five inches
directly
below the navel. Dudingston called for Mr. Dickinson to produce
bandages
and other necessaries for the dressing of the wound, and when finished,
orders were given to the schooner's company to collect their clothing
and
every thing belonging to them and put them into their boats, as all of
them were to be sent on shore.
All were soon collected and put on board
of the boats, including one of our boats. They departed and landed
Dudingston
at the old Still-house Wharf, at Pawtuxet, and put the chief into the
house
of Joseph Rhodes.
Soon after, all the party were ordered to depart,
leaving
one boat for the leaders of the expedition, who soon set the vessel on
fire, which consumed her to the waters' edge.
The names of the most conspicuous actors are as follows, viz: Mr. John Brown1, Captains Abraham Whipple2, John B. Hopkins3, Benjamin Dunn, and five others, whose names I have forgotten, and John Mawney4, Benjamin Page5, Joseph Bucklin6, and Turpin Smith7, my youthful companions, all of whom are dead, I believe, every man of the party, excepting myself, and my age is eighty-six years this 29th day of August, 1839.
Mr.
John Mawney, who was one of the party conspicuous in the affair,
published in the Providence American
and Gazette, in the year 1826, a statement, in which some
additional facts are given.
After hearing the drum beat, he repaired to Mr. Sabin's, the place of rendezvous, where he learned the object of the meeting; and on being urged by some of his acquaintances, was induced to accompany them, as surgeon.
Statement
of Dr. John Mawney.
"To this," he says, "I readily consented, and went to Corlis' wharf
with Capt. Joseph Tillinghast, who commanded the barge, it being the
last
boat that put off, and in going down we stopped at Capt. Cooke's wharf,
where we took in staves and paving stones, which done followed our
commander
and came up with them a considerable distance down the river, after
which
we rowed along pretty rapidly till we came in sight of the schooner,
when
Capt. (the late Commodore Whipple,) ordered us to form a line, which
was
instantly complied with, after which we rowed gently along, till we had
got near the schooner, when we were hailed from on board with the
words,
'Who comes there?"
Capt. Whipple replied, 'I want to come on board."
The
reply was, "Stand off, you can't come on board."
On which Capt. Whipple
roared out, "I am the sheriff of the county of Kent, I am come for the
commander of this vessel, and have him I will, dead or alive; men,
spring
to your oars;" when we were in an instant on her bows.
I was then sitting with Capt. Tillinghast in the stern of the barge, and sprang immediately forward, and seeing a rope hang down her bows, seized it to help myself in. The rope slipping, I fell almost to my waist in the water, but being active and nimble, I recovered, and was the first of our crew on deck, when Simeon H. Olney handed me a stave, with which, seeing one that I took to be of the crew of the schooner, floundering below the windlass, I was in the attitude of leveling a stroke, when he cried out, "John, don't strike."
Being very intimately acquainted with Capt. Samuel Dunn, I
knew
his voice, left him, and sprung back of the windlass, where there was
commotion
and noise, but which soon subsided, the crew jumping down the hold, I
immediately
following, when I ordered them to bring cords to tie their hands, and
told
them they should not be hurt but be sent on shore. They brought some
tarred
strings, with which I tied the hands of two behind, when John Brown,
Esq.,
called to me saying, I was wanted immediately on deck, where I was
instantly
helped.
When I asked Mr. Brown what is the matter, he replied, "Don't
call
names, but go immediately into the cabin, there is one wounded, and
will
bleed to death."
I hastened into the cabin and found Lieut. Dudingston
in a sitting posture, gently reclining to the left, bleeding profusely,
with a thin, white, woolen blanket, loose about him, which I threw
aside
and discovered the effect of a musket ball in his left groin, and
thinking
the femoral artery was cut, threw open my waistcoat and taking my shirt
by the collar, tore it to my waistband, when Mr. Dudingston said,
"Pray,
sir, don't tear your clothes, there is linen in that trunk," upon which
I requested Joseph Bucklin to break open the trunk and tear linen and
scrape
lint, which he immediately attempted, but finding the linen new and
strong,
could not make the lint.
I then directed him to place his hands as I had mine, which was, the
ball of my left hand on the orifice of the wound, and giving him the
word
to slip his hand under mine and to press hard to prevent the effusion
of
blood; which being done, I went to the linen and attempted to scrape it
into lint, but found I could not effect it. As daylight was fast coming
on and our time short, I then tore the linen into strips for compresses
and the necessary bandages, which was done by knotting them into long
strips,
placed the compresses five or six deep, and with the ligatures, by the
lieutenant
All being prepared, I told Bucklin to raise his hands, when I
instantly
placed the compresses on the orifice, and placing the bandage round the
thigh over the wound and crossing it above, drew tight, so that the
effusion
of blood was stopped.
During the operation, I was several times called
upon at the door, but now was ready. When the door was opened many
rushed
in and attacked the bottles. I having boots on, stamped on them, and
requested
others to assist, which was readily done. During this, Mr. Dudingston
was
carried out of the room, and I never saw him after, notwithstanding I
had
several invitations, through Dr. Henry Sterling.
When I came on deck I
saw Capt. Tillinghast, and some others. We got into the boat and rowed
up the river a certain distance and went by land to town, when Capt.
Tillinghast,
who was then living with me, after taking breakfast, went on the hill
to
view the smoking ruins of the vessel, which was all in flames soon
after
we left it."*
This statement
of Dr. Mawney, differs somewhat from that of Col. Bowen, though in
nothing that is material. It is quite natural that among so many
men, incidents might take place which all did not observe.
The attention of Dr. Mawney was particularly directed to
the
wounded officer, though, it would appear that he had been ready to
inflict,
as
to cure wounds.
"From a subsequent statement of Dr. Mawney, it appears that Lieut. Dudingston was not wanting in gratitude to his surgeon. After his wound was dressed, he offered Dr. Mawney a gold stock buckle as a testimonial of his gratitude.
_______________________This was refused,
but a silver one was afterward
offered
and accepted, and worn by Dr. Mawney but a little while before his
death."*
The first official notice of the destruction of the Gaspee, is a letter
from Deputy Governor
Sessions to Governor Wanton, written the day following that event,
after he paid a visit to Lieut. Dudingston, at Pawtuxet. It
appears that the first act of the Deputy Governor, on hearing of the
affair, was to see the wounded officer, and endevour to do all that lay
in his power to ameliorate his sufferings, and administer to his
comforts.
It is the prevailing opinion of the gentlemen in this quarter, that a proclamation, with a large reward, be issued for the apprehending the persons who have thus offended. You will please consult the gentlemen your way, and in the meantime, I will endeavor to collect the sentiments of the members of the Assembly, and other principal gentlemen by name and send the same to your honor as soon as may be.
I am, &c, &c.,
Enclosed in this letter
were the following affidavits:
Affidavit
of Bartholomew Cheever.
The examination of Bartholomew
Cheever, seaman, lately belonging to
his Majesty's schooner, the Gaspee, taken by Darius Sessions, deputy
governor
of the colony of Rhode Island, &c., is as followeth, viz:
That the
said schooner being bound from Newport up to Providence, to take on
board
some of his Majesty's seamen that were expected from Boston, did, on
the
9th of this instant, at about three o'clock in the afternoon of said
day,
run aground on a point of land, about six miles below the town of
Providence,
where she, the said schooner, lay until twelve o'clock at night, at
which
time he, the said Cheever, was called upon deck to take the watch;
about
three-quarters of an hour afterwards, the schooner yet being aground,
he
observed some long boats, about six or seven in number, full of men,
drawing
near to the schooner, upon which he informed the commander, Capt.
Dudingston,
who immediately came on deck, and ordered him to hail them and bid them
stand off on their peril, to which they answered, "Damn you, we have
you."
The captain then ordered him to
call all hands on deck, which he
did;
but
before many of them got up, the boats were alongside and the crews
getting
on board; and as they were entering the schooner, he saw the flash and
heard the report of a musket, and heard the captain cry out, he was a
dead
man.
We were then ordered into the hold, and taken out separately and put into the boats alongside, the most of us being pinioned, and then put on shore on the main land, where we had not been long before we saw the schooner on fire, where she continued burning till the fire reached the water's edge.
Question—Did you, or do you know, or do you remember ever to have seen before any of those persons that boarded the schooner at that time?
Answer—No.
Affidavits of John Johnson and William J. Caple.
Question—Have you any knowledge of the persons that boarded the schooner?
Answer—No.
On the following day, June 12, Governor Sessions addressed another letter to Gov. Wanton. The bearer of which, probably brought the proclamation of Governor Wanton, which follows:
Your honor's most humble servant,
A PROCLAMATION.
Whereas, on Tuesday, the 9th
inst., in the night, a number of people
unknown, boarded his Majesty's armed schooner the Gaspee, as she lay
aground
on a point of land called Namquit, a little to the southward of
Pawtuxet,
in the colony aforesaid, who dangerously wounded William Dudingston,
the
commander, and by force took him with all his people, put them into
boats,
and landed them near Pawtuxet, and afterward set fire to the said
schooner,
whereby she was totally destroyed.
I have, therefore, thought fit, by
and
with the advice of such of his Majesty's council as could be seasonably
convened to issue this proclamation, strictly charging and commanding
all
his majesty's officers within the said colony, both civil and military,
to exert themselves with the utmost vigilance to discover and apprehend
the persons guilty of the aforesaid atrocious crime, that they may be
brought
to condign punishment.
And I do hereby offer a reward of one hundred pounds sterling money of Great Britain to any person or persons who shall discover the perpetrators of the said villainy, to be paid immediately upon the conviction of any one or more of them.
And the several sheriffs in the said colony are hereby required forthwith to cause this proclamation to be posted up in the most public places in each of the towns in their respective countries.
Given under my hand and seal at arms at Newport this 12th day of June, in the twelfth year of the reign of his Most Sacred Majesty George the Third, by the Grace of God, King of Great Britain and so forth, Anno Dom. 1772.
HENRY WARD, Secretary.God save the King.
The deposition enclosed was that of William Dickinson, which was as follows:
Deposition
of William Dickinson.
William Dickinson, midshipman of
his Majesty's schooner Gaspee,
sayeth:
That the said schooner was at
single anchor about three leagues
below
Providence,
in Rhode Island government, 10th of June, 1772, and about half past
twelve
o'clock in the night or morning, the watch gave the alarm that a number
of boats were coming down the river, and very near us, (being an
exceeding
dark night,) we hailed them, and ordered them to keep off.
They
instantly
gave us three cheers, on which we fired at them with muskets, which
they
immediately returned with half a dozen muskets, (or thereabouts.) We
then
fired our pistols, on which they boarded us upon the starboard bow, and
fired a number of small arms. Immediately Lieutenant Dudingston (her
commander)
cried out, "Good God, I am done for." He was wounded in his groin and
arm.
When they had got possession of
the schooner they used the people very ill, by pinioning of them, and
throwing
them into their boats, and refused the Lieutenant and officers any
necessaries
but what they had on, and not even suffered the commanding officer to
have
his papers, and robbed his servant of several silver spoons, and
throwed
his linen and apparel overboard.
Question.—How long had you
been lying in Providence River?
Answer.—We came to an anchor there at about 4 o'clock in the
afternoon of the 9th of June.
Q,—Had you sent any boat ashore?
A.—No, but employed sounding the Harbor.
Q.—Had you been at Providence before during the time you were
upon that station?
A.—No.
Q —Do you imagine that the people who boarded you, came from
Providence?
A.—Yes; I believe the most part, but cannot say all, as one
boat landed her men at Pawtuxet.
Q.—What distance is Pawtuxet from Providence by land?
A.—Five miles.
Q.—What distance were the boats from the schooner when they
were first seen?
A.—I was not upon deck at first myself, but when I saw them
they were about 100 yards.
Q.—Why did you not fire your great guns at them?
A.—They boarded us upon the bows, and were so near to us that
we had not time to get our guns out at the bow ports.
Q.—Did any of the people that boarded you appear like gentlemen?
A.—Yes; many of them appeared like men of credit and tradesmen,
and but few like common men.
Q.—Did they make use of any opprobrious language?
A.—Yes; by threatening to put the Lieutenant to death, and
calling
us piratical rascals.
Q.—Where did you leave the Beaver?
A.—Off Golden Island, in the mouth of Seaconnet Passage.
Q.—What distance from you?
A.—About twenty-five miles.
Q.—Could she be in sight when this happened?
A.—No; the main land is between.
Q. —Is there any thing more that you can recollect?
A.—Yes; one of the people took me by the collar, and said, "Damn
you, where is your Pilot Doget." I answered he was discharged six weeks
ago. He answered, "Damn your blood, you lie;'' and said they would find
him, and tlee him alive.
Q.—Did they suffer the
lieutenant to put on any clothes after
he was wounded?
A.—No; he was in his shirt with his great coat over his
shoulders,
and a blanket round his body.
Q.—Was any other person wounded except the lieutenant?
A.—Yes; one in the head.
And I further declare, that when
Lieutenant Dudingston came on deck,
I saw him go and stand by the starboard foreshrouds, in his shirt, with
a pistol in one hand and a hanger in the other. After he was wounded he
got aft and sat down by the cabin companion way, when the two
ringleaders,
with a number following them, came to him and said,
"Now you piratical
rascal, we have got you. Damn you, we will hang you all by the laws of
Great Britain. Damn you, what made you fire when we answered you that
the
head sheriff was in the boat."
The Captain (N.B. The head sheriff
and captain are fictitious names
that the two ringleaders went by) said, "Stand aside and let me
despatch
the piratical dog."
He then lifted a handspike over
Mr. Dudingston's
head,
who asked "if they would give no quarters."
They answered, "No."
He
then
desired they would let me bind up his wounds, for he was shot, and
showed
them the wound in his left arm.
They then said, "Damn your blood,
you
are
shot by your own people."
He was then taken down into the
cabin by some
of the mob. They then pinioned me and put me into the boat, where I
remained
for half an hour, when one of the mob called to their people in the
boat
to loose me for the Lieutenant wanted me. I went down in the cabin to
him.
He was laid on the after lockers, and one of the mob washing and
binding
up his wounds. The mob then got him on deck and put him in a boat and
put
off.
Soon after, I was ordered into the boat again, and put off. In going on shore I saw a negro with the Lieutenant's hanger; being asked by another how he got it, he said he took it from the Captain.
Being down in the cabin with
Lieutenant Dudingston, the ringleaders
and some of the principal of the mob demanded his papers and orders for
his proceeding in such piratical manner. I then showed them the
commission
from the Lords of the Admiralty, with all his orders and instructions
that
he had received from the Admiral, which they took and carried away.
In going ashore one of the mob that rowed the boat said, that he and several more would not have been there, but that they were taken out of a house by force and compelled to go; that they beat a drum round the town of Providence in the evening to raise a mob.
I have not, as yet, been able to collect all the circumstances of this daring insult upon authority, so as to give you a perfect idea of it, but by the evidence of three of the people of the Gaspee, taken before his honor the deputy governor, copies of which I transmit, you will perceive that there is a material difference between them and the account given by William Dickinson.
You may rely upon the utmost and
continued exertions of the officers
of this Colony to detect and bring to justice the perpetrators of this
violent outrage.
I have the pleasure to inform you that Lieutenant Dudingston is in a fair way of recovery.
I am, sir, &c, &c
On the 12th,
Lieutenant
Dudingston had so far recovered as to be able to write
a letter to Admiral
Montagu, wherein he presented his version of the destruction of
the vessel. This differs but little from those of Col. Bowen and
Dr. Mawney. as to the attack on the boats, his being wounded and the
surrender of his vessel to an overpowering force.
The schooner is utterly destroyed, and every thing appertaining to her, me, and the schooner's company. If I live, I am not without hope of being able to convict some of the principal people that were with them. The pain with the loss of blood rendered me incapable of informing you before of the particulars. There are none of the people any ways wounded, but bruised with handspikes.
I am, sir, &c, &c,.
I offered to be security for him; but Capt. Dudingston told me he should not ask any person to be security, as he did not expect to live long, and the sheriff might do as he pleased. The surgeons told me he was too ill to be moved; and as I expect the sheriff will use great severity with him, I humbly request Your Honors to give me such direction in the matter as to you shall seem necessary.*
I am, &c., &c.,
It will not bear a dispute but that they belonged to Providence, as they were heard by four or five gentlemen that were in the town, and are now here, beating the drum to arms to raise a body of people to destroy the King's schooner. I have persued the depositions which your Excellency enclosed, and although they differ in words, yet the matter is much to the same purpose.
I have, since I received yours,
received one from Lieutenant
Dudingston,
whose account nearly agrees with the other, with this addition only:
that
when he was carried down to his cabin, after he was wounded, he, to his
great surprise found two surgeons that came off from the shore in the
boats,
ready to dress his wounds, with drops and scraping of lint, and at
least
a dozen of these people who were in the cabin, which were at his bureau
reading and examining his papers, appeared to him to be merchants and
masters
of vessels.
It gives me pleasure to hear the Lieutenant is in a fair way of recovery.
I am , sir, &c, &c.
By the enclosed deposition, Your
Lordship will see that this nest of
daring smugglers have wounded in a most dangerous manner Lieut.
Dudingston,
and burnt the King's schooner Gaspee, under his command, for no other
cause,
except his being dilligent in the discharge of his duty, by giving
every
proper assistance to the fair trader, and using every endeavor to
suppress
the illicit trade that is carried on to a great degree, in that
province,
and which can never be checked unless there are more men-of-war
stationed
there, to keep the inhabitants in order.
I beg leave to refer Your Lordship to the enclosed deposition, for the particulars, and wait Your Lordship's instructions for what is to be done. Permit me to add, that the lieutenant that is wounded, is a sober, dilligent, good officer; and has most strictly done his duty since I have had the honor of commanding here, frequently at the hazard of his life, in assisting the revenue. Should he survive, which I have little hopes of, I beg leave to recommend him to Your Lordship's favor and protection.
I have the honor, &c., &c.,
P.S. Herewith I transmit to Your Lordship copies of letters which have passed between me, Lieutenant Dudingston and the Governor of Rhode Island, which I did not think necessary to trouble Your Lordship with.until this melancholy affair of the schooner happened.
The following is the official account of the destruction of the Gaspee, transmitted by Governor Wanton to the Earl of Hillsborough.
On the 9th inst., she run aground
on a point of land called Namquit,
a little below Pawtuxet, on the Narragansett River, within this Colony.
About three quarters of an hour after 12 o'clock at night, there being
but one hand on deck, six or seven boats, full of men, were by him
discovered
drawing towards said schooner; and before many of her hands had time to
get upon deck, was boarded by the people in the boats, who, as soon as
they had secured the possession of the schooner, took out the captain
and
all the people and set them ashore on the main land. After which they
set
fire to the schooner. In the attack, Wm. Dudingston was wounded by a
ball
through his arm, from whence it passed and lodged in some part of his
body.
Mr. Sessions, the deputy governor
of this Colony, immediately upon
hearing
of this unhappy affair, went to Wm. Dudingston, and offered him all the
help and assistance in his power, but Mr. Dudingston said he wanted no
favors for himself. The deputy governor then told him that he came not
only to offer him any relief his distressed circumstances might
require,
but also to gain a declaration from his own mouth respecting the
destruction
of the schooner under his command, that proper and rigorous measures
might
be taken to discover and bring the perpetrators to justice.
Mr.
Dudingston
answered, he would give him no account because of his indisposition,
and
also, because it was his duty to forbear any thing of that kind, till
he
had done it to his commanding officer, at a court martial, to which, if
he lived, he must be called, but if he died, he desired it might all
die
with him.
The deputy governor, with the consent of Mr. Dudingston, then proceeded to examine a number of his men, and on the 11th transmitted copies of the most material of the examinations to me; upon the receipt whereof, I immediately convened such of his Majesty's council and the house of deputies as could be seasonably notified, and laid before them the proceedings of the deputy governor, which they highly approved of, and unanimously recommended my issuing a proclamation, with a reward of £100 sterling for the discovery of any of the persons concerned in this violent insult upon government, which I cheerfully complied with, and sent them into the several towns in this Colony.
This transaction gives me the utmost uneasiness, and your Lordship may be assured, that the utmost vigilance of the civil authority will not be wanting to bring the perpetrators to exemplary and condign punishment; and injustice to the inhabitants of the Colony, I must not omit mentioning, that the conduct of those who committed this outrage is, by them, universally condemned.
I wish, my Lord, those officers
who have lately been sent into this
Colony, under a pretence of assisting trade, had conducted with that
temper,
prudence and discretion which persons entrusted with the execution of
the
laws ought, upon every occasion, to manifest.
In my last, I informed your
Lordship, that the inhabitants had been
insulted without any just cause, and I am extremely sorry that I have
still
reason to say, that the trade of this Colony is interrupted in a most
unprecedented
and oppressive manner, without contributing, in the least, to the
service
of the revenue. Inward bound vessels have been detained several days
without
the least colorable pretext, and then delivered up.
One from South
Kingstown,
for having on board a small quantity of tobacco of the growth of this
Colony,
which the owner was transporting to Newport for a market; another for
having
only three or four dozen wine laid in by the Captain for sea stores.
The
small freight boats plying between the several towns with the produce
of
the Colony, are, by the severity of these officers, subjected to great
inconvenience, which very sensibly affects the whole Colony,
particularly
the town of Newport, its metropolis, whose inhabitants are principally
supplied with the necessaries of life by water, and the obstructions
they
now experience have contributed not a little to enhance the price of
fuel
and provisions, to the great disadvantage of the town; and in my humble
opinion, if such measures are permitted to be pursued, the Colony will
ere long be involved in the deepest calamity.
These, my Lord, are serious and important truths; and as your Lordship, from your thorough knowledge of the Colony, must be perfectly acquainted with the nature and extent of our trade, the profits of which ultimately centering in Great Britain, for the purchase of her manufactures, I have no room to doubt of your Lordship's interposition in behalf of this Colony, that all cause of complaint against any of the King's officers stationed here may be removed, and the inhabitants treated with that respect which is due to the subjects of his Britannic Majesty.
As a proof, my Lord, that the trade of this Colony stands upon as fair and legal a footing as the trade of any part of his Majesty's dominions, out of two hundred sail of vessels which have entered this port since the first day of March last, only two in that number have been prosecuted and condemned for breach of acts of trade, one of which belongs to the Massachusetts Bay, notwithstanding they have been searched and rummaged with the greatest severity. These two vessels, although seized and condemned here, were sent by Capt. Linzee, of the Beaver, and Lieutenant Dudingston, to Boston, for sale, in direct opposition to the orders of the court of Vice Admiralty within this Colony, and the marshal of said court prevented by force from libelling one of these vessels for payment of the mariners' wages.
These, my Lord, are but a few of
the many grievances which the
people
of this Colony have been for months past harassed and perplexed with;
but
as the General Assembly will be convened, I make no doubt they will
order
a more particular remonstrance to be made.